Hermès Kelly or Birkin? A closer look at two icons

When thinking of luxury handbags, the names Hermès Kelly and Birkin immediately come to mind. These bags have become synonymous with exclusivity, sophistication, and craftsmanship. While both bags have achieved iconic status within the fashion world, they are different in many ways. In this blog, we will dive deeper into what sets these two models apart and why they are such beloved items for collectors and fashion-conscious women.

1. The origin: Kelly vs. Birkin

The Kelly bag has been around much longer than the Birkin, originally designed in the 1930s as the “Sac à Dépêches”. It really became famous when actress and Princess Grace Kelly appeared on the cover of Life magazine in 1956 with the bag, which she used to hide her baby bump. From then on, the bag was officially renamed the “Kelly”, and it became a symbol of timeless elegance.

The Birkin bag has a different story and is a product of the 80s. The design came about after a chance meet-up between actress Jane Birkin and Hermès CEO Jean-Louis Dumas. During a flight, Birkin complained about the lack of practical handbags, so Dumas decided to design a bag especially for her. And so the Birkin was born in 1984, a bag that has since become a symbol of effortless luxury and functionality.

2. The design and closure

Although both bags breathe luxury, they differ in design and functionality. The Kelly has a sleeker, more elegant silhouette and is more formal. It has a single handle and an iconic flap that is closed with a clasp and a narrow strap. This makes the bag less accessible, as you have to open the strap to get to the contents. However, this does give the Kelly a refined, structured look that is often associated with elegance and business occasions.

The Birkin has a looser, more casual feel and is often seen as the more practical option of the two. The Birkin has two handles and a more spacious, open construction, making it easier to quickly get items in and out of the bag. The bag does close with a strap, but many users tend to leave it open for a more casual look. The design is less structured than the Kelly, which contributes to its more casual and versatile style.

3. Wearing style and functionality

One of the biggest differences between the two bags is the way they are worn. The Kelly is often carried in the hand or on the arm, but it also has a long shoulder strap so you can wear it crossbody or over the shoulder. This makes the Kelly more versatile, especially if you are looking for a bag that can also be worn formally.

The Birkin, on the other hand, has no shoulder strap and is usually carried by hand or over the arm. This can sometimes be limiting, especially if you want a bag that can be carried hands-free. Despite this, the Birkin is often praised for its spacious interior, making it a practical choice for everyday use while still retaining that iconic Hermès look.

4. Sizes and formats

Both bags come in a variety of sizes, with the number behind the bag indicating the width in centimeters. The Kelly ranges from the smaller Kelly 20 to the larger Kelly 35, meaning you can choose a size that suits your personal style and needs. The smaller sizes are often worn as an evening bag, while the larger sizes are more suitable for everyday use.

The Birkin typically comes in sizes ranging from 25 cm to 40 cm. The Birkin 25 is petite and cute, perfect for evening occasions, while the Birkin 35 and 40 are popular for everyday use thanks to their spacious interiors. This size difference gives the Birkin a reputation as a more versatile option if you’re looking for a bag that’s both chic and practical.

5. Prices and availability

Both bags are famous for their exclusivity. They are often hard to come by, with long waiting lists for new ones. The price of a new Kelly typically starts at around €8,000, depending on material and size, while the Birkin tends to be more expensive, starting at around €10,000 or more.

Pre-owned bags and special editions can often sell for even higher prices. The value can even increase significantly, given the scarcity and demand for rare models. Special editions, rare colors and exotic materials can drive prices up even further.

6. Why These Bags Are Iconic

Both the Kelly and the Birkin are more than just handbags. They are status symbols, collectibles and cultural icons. Their handcrafted construction and use of the finest materials make them true masterpieces of craftsmanship. The long waiting lists and limited availability add to their exclusivity. What’s more, celebrities and royals wear these bags, adding to their iconic status.

Conclusion

The choice between the Hermès Kelly and the Birkin depends on your personal style and needs. The Kelly is perfect for those looking for a formal, structured bag that exudes elegance, while the Birkin is ideal for women who want a roomier, more casual bag that still offers luxury and style. Both bags are icons in the fashion world, but each has its own unique charm and history. What they have in common is that they represent the highest form of luxury and exclusivity, making them the ultimate dream bag for many. Now the challenge is to get your hands on one...